About Us

Who We Are

At Crawford Agency, we are a team of dedicated insurance professionals committed to providing exceptional service to our community. Our knowledgeable staff, with decades of combined experience, works tirelessly to ensure you receive the best coverage tailored to your unique needs. We pride ourselves on our personalized approach, treating each client like family and staying readily available to address any concerns. Today, we continue to uphold the values of trust, integrity, and reliability that have been the cornerstone of our agency for over 76 years. Whether you're looking for home, auto, business, or life insurance, our team is here to guide you every step of the way.
Our History

Andrew Crawford, Jr. entered the independent insurance agency business with the purchase of the Dean T. Ford agency in 1944. The agency operated under that name until 1952 when the name was officially changed to Crawford Agency, Inc. The office moved to our present location of 55 South Forest Street, Geneva, Ohio in 1958, with an addition built in 1978 to accommodate our growing needs.


Andrew’s son Terry joined the agency full time in 1964 and son James came on board in 1969. Andrew served as President until 1969 when son Terry took over the Presidency and served until 1989 when he moved to Florida. Jim Crawford presently serves as President since he assumed the role in 1989. Betsy Deering joined the agency in 1967 and had served until 2017 as the Personal Lines Manager. She retired after 50 years of service!  Kim Domino joined the agency in 1989 and currently serves as Personal Lines Manager. Pat Traylor is our commercial lines manager and has been an agent for 42 years and with the agency for 25. Jim’s step-son Michael joined the staff in 1990. Michael serves as the Vice President of the corporation and has recently moved to commercial lines.

How We Got Here

Meet Our Team

A man in a white shirt is smiling for the camera

Jim Crawford

President/Agent

  • Read More

    Jim is a second generation Agent, taking over as President after his father and brother retired from the Agency. After 50 years with the Agency he is now semi-retired himself, allowing him to spend more time with his wife, Barb, and family.

A bald man in a suit and white shirt smiles for the camera

Mike Goddard

Vice President
/Agent
  • Read More

    Mike is Jim’s step-son and has been with the Agency for 30 years. When not at work, he enjoys spending time with his three children – John, Mick & Clare – and golfing when he gets the chance.

A woman wearing glasses and a blue shirt is smiling for the camera.

Patricia Traylor

Commercial Lines Manager/Agent
  • Read More

    Pat has over 40 years of insurance experience and has been with the Agency for over 20 years. Outside of work she enjoys spending time with her husband, visiting antique malls, and cruising on their Harley. She is also a Notary Public.

A woman wearing a yellow and black shirt is smiling for the camera.

Kimberly Domino, CISR

Personal Lines Manager/Agent
  • Read More

    Kim has been with the Agency for over 30 years and is a Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR), showing her dedication to providing exceptional customer service. When not at work, she enoys spending time with her husband, 2 daughters and pomeranian, Meeko.

It is a picture of a person without a face.

New
Employee

More to Come
  • Coming Soon

    Check Back Later!

A woman with a ponytail is smiling for the camera

Emily Nicholson

Accounting/Commercial Lines Agent
  • Read More

    Emily has been with the Agency for 5 years. She enjoys spending her free time with her husband, her son Tyler, and their beagle, Grace.

A man wearing glasses and a blue and white polo shirt

Doug Alvord, LUTCF

Life Insurance Agent

  • Read More

    Doug has been with the Crawford Life Insurance Agency for over 40 years. In his free time he enjoys traveling with Brenda, his wife of 46 years, his children, and his new grandchildren.